Music education always & always looking forward.

Phrygian (or Locrian?!) Mode in Jefferson Airplane's "White Rabbit"

God bless the 1960s.  And God bless all of the interest in classical music and theory that came with the psychedelic movement.  I'm serious!  This song is as good for any in bringing up the discussion of "what mode is this - really!?" for students.  Or among yourselves.  Either way.

Need some theory memory jogging?  Let me tell you my story about learning how modes work.  In 10th grade, I was not only an obsessive Smashing Pumpkins fan, but I was a huge nerd who lived for marching and studied music theory on her own time.  I used the site Teoria, a theory learning site based in Puerto Rico (with lessons both in English and Spanish!), to learn a lot of basics ahead of time, and I was very grateful for such.  When it came to memorizing modes, I made myself a mnemonic: I Don't Phart Like My Aunt Lucrecia.  Boy was I a cool 16-yr-old.

These words in this nonsense sentence stand for the seven modes we often hear in Western music: Ionian, Dorian, Phrygian, Lydian, Mixolydian, Aeolian, and Locrian.  Ionian mode is your typical, diatonic major scale (do re mi fa sol la ti do), Aeolian is your natural minor scale, Dorian is commonly used in pop and jazz music but is often mistaken for minor/Aeolian mode, etc.  Here, however, "White Rabbit", which is a pretty enigmatic song itself, is not in a terribly clear mode.  The first two chords of the song are F# and G, and the rest of the chords in the song don't really give us a clear conclusion as to whether the song is in F# Phrygian (based on the D scale) or F# Locrian (which is even weirder, and based on the G scale).  Based on what I hear/see, I'd argue for Phrygian, but it's surely up for debate. 

This is why they call it music "theory".  Only Grace Slick really knows, and considering that she wrote the song with a strong anti-authority bent, she probably wasn't consulting her music teacher on this one.  We'll actually come back to Grace Slick in two weeks as we're discussing the 1980s, so brace yourself for that one.

ADDITIONAL LINK: I have close to absolutely zero frame of reference in terms of EDM, but this particular article explains modes a little more clearly.  I understand the accompanying artwork a little less clearly.  Enjoy!

“White Rabbit” - Jefferson Airplane

Intro: Jefferson Airplane is a band inextricably linked with the 1960s. The group helped to define psychedelia as a musical style and formed the basis of the late 60s San Francisco sound. Forming in San Francisco in 1965, the group experienced a major boon when Grace Slick joined in 1966. Slick had already written "White Rabbit" and co-written the band's other Top Ten hit, "Somebody to Love" before joining the band and both became massive hits, appearing on Jefferson Airplane's 1967 album Surrealistic Pillow. "White Rabbit" reached #8 on the Billboard Hot 100 and has been cited as a major influence on rock music, appearing on the Rock and Roll Hall of Fame's list of Top 500 Songs that Shaped Rock and Roll. 

Analysis: Although publishing outlets claim this song is in F# minor, the song could be considered in either F# Phrygian mode or F# Locrian mode. The first two chords heard in the song are F# and G, with the minor second creating the harmonic tension that the song is famous for. Phrygian mode starts on the third scale degree of a major diatonic scale -- in this case, F# is the third scale degree of D major. You could defend the Phrygian mode argument based on the final chord of the song, as it ends on an A major chord, reinforcing a key that is based on D major (as A is the V chord of D major). Additionally, every chord in the song is a major chord, thus the F# chord uses a C#, which would appear in F# Phrygian mode. However, if you analyze the song on the basis of chords that appear in the song, you could argue that the song is in F# Locrian mode (meaning that the mode is based on G major, as F# is the seventh scale degree of that scale). Every chord of the song begins on a note found in G major, however, the final A major chord would not appear the same way in any scale based on G major.

Considerations for Teaching: While the song makes no overt reference to illegal drugs, but rather direct reference to Lewis Carroll's children's books about young Alice, Grace Slick wrote it with reference to drug culture in mind. The psychedelic musical movement was almost entirely populated by musicians who were also heavy drug users, which often comes up in discussion when talking about this musical era. The song is often used in film and popular culture to portray a world turned upside down, sometimes violently, as seen in the film The Game. Despite these precautions, the song is an excellent example to use when introducing modes in advanced theory classes.
 

Top Ten Favorite Things About Lin-Manuel Miranda's Hamilton

Flattened Submediant Modulation in the Beach Boys' "Wouldn't It Be Nice?"